Margaret Thatcher once said that climate change "provides a marvelous excuse for worldwide, supranational socialism.". A Conservative Answer to Climate Change - WSJ News Corp is a global, diversified media and information services company focused on creating and distributing authoritative and engaging content and. (+1) 202-419-4300 | Main Republican support is rising, Inglis believes. Smith attributes this increased polarization to a falsebeliefthat science and hardline conservative politics are mutually exclusive. Legislation on climate change, such as the Climate Action Now Act, is also frequently decided along party lines. To be fair, Democrats havent been swayed either. (+1) 202-857-8562 | Fax We typically think of conservatives (both small-c and big-C) as being in favour of smaller government and market-based solutions. We surveyed 13,749 U.S. adults from April 20 to 29, 2021. For example, roughly nine-in-ten Democrats (92%) support requiring power companies to use more energy from renewable sources, such as wind and solar power a component of President Joe Bidens infrastructure plan. The survey was conducted on Pew Research Centers American Trends Panel (ATP) and included an oversample of adults ages 18 to 24 from the Ipsos Knowledge Panel. Our conservative values are not only part of our identity, they are key to effective climate solutions." To eliminate the emissions that are fueling global temperature rise, we need to switch. I am totally ready to be judged a year from on how much impact weve had on the debate. Younger Democrats are more likely than older Democrats to support breaking with all fossil fuels and to favor phasing out gasoline-powered cars and trucks by 2035. When it comes to climate change, most of us think we know where the battle lines are drawn: On one side, progressives believe a warming planet is a global emergency and advocate sweeping Green New Deal policies to address it. Whether it's kale or Kobe beef, producing food accounts for some measure of greenhouse gasses. On Wednesday, Curtis introduced the new Republican-only Conservative Climate Caucus, aimed at educating. The Paris climate change negotiations won't end until later this week, but we already know what will happen. The political debate over climate change has long resembled a contest to see which party can discredit itself more. That's the hard kernel of truth at the heart of this conspiracy to make federal Conservatives stop ignoring climate change. Two stories were particularly effective at shifting conservatives' personal climate change beliefs. So I would think this is a little bit of a litmus test for them. This finding aligns with reports of disproportionate environmental hazards in large Black, Hispanic and Asian American communities. There are wide and growing differences between Democrats and Republicans in these judgments. You also have to be really careful: weve always had extreme weather events. This includes incentives for renewable energy, research into ways to scrub carbon from smokestack emissions, and backing for safe new nuclear technologies. There is No Climate Emergency. Do you think the caucus is trying to deescalate that and how do you go about doing that? The public has mixed views about the depth of expertise that climate scientists have on key questions related to climate change. Conservatives who reject the science of climate change aren't necessarily reacting to the science, according to a new study from researchers at Duke University.They're reacting to the fact that they don't like proposed solutions more strongly identified with liberals. I think that conservation feeds into the identity of conservatism because were trying to protect what we have right now to give it to the next generation.. If theyre standing at the back taking shots at us, I tend to say, Well, its just political to you and your only concerned about political points and youre worried about that.. In 2021, only 29% of Republicans believe climate change has already begun compared to 46% in 1993. He thinks Democrats may be making a mistake in calling climate change a crisis and says his caucus wont endorse specific legislation to address the problem. 2 Arizona, Sharon Stone: I 'lost half my money' in Silicon Valley Bank collapse. Comments are welcome while open. Some 3,500 economists, including 27 Nobel laureates, have endorsed the idea. Conservatives And Climate Change. Read our research on: Congress | Economy | Gender. By John Gustavsson. I understand solutions. (He lost his reelection bid in 2010, partly as a result of his stance on climate change, and now works to promote free-market climate solutions). And I read from that theyre genuine about changing the environmental picture. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. It is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts. In sum, climate change is as much a political problem as it is a scientific or technical one. It would begin by fixing a widely known flaw of free markets: their tendency to produce negative. Aside from the bureaucracy involved (which seems horrendous), this moves from a simple system of incentivizing emissions reductions to a complex and restrictive one that makes life more complicated, not less. Looking at climate-related content from 33 prominent climate contrarian blogs and 20 conservative think-tanks produced between 1998 and 2020, the team began by sorting the climate claims into . This Conservative plan is better late than never, and certainly better than the last one, but on many of the key climate policy issues it appears to be merely change for the sake of change, writes climate and energy policyeconomist Jennifer Winter. The task force is saying theyre going to show us the results in five years, Smith said. Few Republicans and Republican-leaning independents express deep concern about addressing climate change: Only 10% call it a top personal concern, compared with a much larger share of Democrats and Democratic leaners (49%), according to a recent Pew Research Center survey of U.S. adults. Environmentalist Paul Hawken believes that to motivate action on climate change, the focus needs to be on solutions rather the problem. This can make them challenging to evaluate, especially compared to lengthy (and oh so detailed!) Generational divides in the GOP are more muted on other proposals. Conservative leader Erin O'Toole announces his party's climate plan during an event in Ottawa in April, 2021. By contrast, a majority of Joe Bidens supporters (68%) described climate change as a very important issue. The conservative's response should be to embrace new scientific insights when they seem validated by available knowledge, while offering superior, market-based alternatives to the progressive's favored solutions. They didnt care about the science. And the fault is 100 percent on the Republican Party leaders.. In response to calls from the business community as well as young conservatives, Republicans spearheaded several climate efforts in 2020, introducing the Growing Climate Solutions Act and Trillion . He announced a new Conservative Climate Caucus last month, complete with the backing of nearly a third of House Republicans, in hopes of getting the GOP more comfortable talking about the climate issue and their proposals. Countries that impose their own tax at home would be exempt from the tariff, however. US conservatives holding a big convention are divided on climate issues as basic as whether carbon dioxide is good for the planet and if global warming should be a priority for humanity in this . But large shares across generations consider climate change a top priority and support a range of policies to address it. Supporters of the proposal think this is only fair: Average Americans are not the people flying around in private jets, says Kiera OBrien, founder of the group Young Conservatives for Carbon Dividends. Climate change is a problem of an entirely different order of magnitude, but these past solutions to smaller environmental crises offer lessons. China is opening coal plants faster than we could ever imagine. You dont even have the Democrats on board with you on this. Backer's nonprofit, the American Conservation Coalition, held what it billed as the country's first conservative climate rally in Miami, part of an effort by the 23-year-old activist to convince . So you can see that makes that task that much more difficult if were without nuclear. Look at Covid, right? Here'show to pitch to us. They cited last years Great American Outdoors Act, which garnered bipartisan support for the annual $1.9 billion the act would provideformaintenanceofAmericas national parks andtoconserve the American landscape in a proactive manner. Conservative media are promoting people such as Guy McPherson, who says that we have 10 years left before exponential climate change literally extinguishes life on Earth and that we should somehow . Since 2016, the last time Pew Research Center asked, Democrats have become more likely to rate climate scientists positively in their understanding of whether climate change is occurring and why, while Republicans have become less likely to give these scientists positive marks on these questions. We can do nuclear at large scale and without a carbon footprint and thats something that we cant ignore. At the same time, they say, it wouldnt do enough to address climate change. I think we just hate the question. Jennifer Winter is an associate professor in the Department of Economics and Scientific Director of Energy and Environmental Policy at the School of Public Policy at the University of Calgary. At the same time, however, the plan also creates policy uncertainty by explicitly stating a Conservative government would eliminate the planned Canadian industrial emissions pricing path (to $170 per tonne by 2030). To me, the scientific evidence behind climate change doesnt dispute that ideology.. For industry, particularly those considering large capital investments in long-lived and low-emissions projects or emissions-reducing investments like carbon capture and storage, confidence that Canada will commit to increasingly stringent climate policy is essential. When the public evaluates proposals to address climate change, they have a number of considerations in mind. Republicans, for instance, are far less likely to believe that climate change is real and caused by human activity than are Democrats. She researches Canadian climate and energy policy. And, in 2018, House Republicans passed a mostly symbolic resolution stating their opposition to carbon taxes. But supporters all agree that the key is harnessing the law of supply and demand: Higher prices on products made using fossil fuels will boost demand for cleaner alternatives, they say, while also driving technological innovation. Curbelo and other conservatives who care about climate change have reason to hope that such pragmatism is starting to filter through the rest of the GOP. And while Biden has tied action on climate change to job growth, Republicans have doubts about the economic impact of climate efforts: 59% of Republicans think Bidens plan to rebuild the countrys infrastructure in ways that are aimed at reducing climate change will hurt the U.S. economy. Climate change denial has been rampant in conservative America, but something is shifting. I think sometimes people fight [the Republican approach] because it gives life to fossil fuels, but the reality of it is that for some time, many parts of the world and large parts of the world are going to be using fossil fuels and very dirty fossil fuels, by the way. Nobody has shown me how you adequately deal with China and Russia with their plan. Dec 9, 2015 12:05 AM. Generational differences over climate change appear in both parties, but especially among Republicans and particularly over the role of fossil fuels. Do you have a strong opinion that could add insight, illuminate an issue in the news, or change how people think about an issue? Jim Manzi. Alex Posner, a recent Yale graduate who helped found Students for Carbon Dividends, couldnt agree more. The Green New Deal isnt a serious plan to fix the climate, says Kiera OBrien founder of the group Young Conservatives for Carbon Dividends. But at a recent NATO summit, Trump did volunteer that, climate change is very important to me. He followed that with some vague comments about very crystal clear, clean water and clean air. But green conservatives were cheered that he at least mentioned the issue. Any plan that makes it too expensive to produce goods in the US risks pushing manufacturing to countries with looser environmental rules. The commitment to work with the Biden administration on vehicle emissions standards and standards for industrial emissions also creates policy certainty. Your email address will not be published. All I knew was that if Al Gore was for it, I was against it, the former South Carolina congressman says. At the same time, the public has limited appetite for some of the more dramatic proposed changes to energy consumption, such as phasing out the use of fossil fuels entirely or ending the production of gasoline-powered vehicles by 2035, according to a new Pew Research Center survey. It also reveals a new political reality. And it begins with. In a recent phone interview, Curtis said hes wary of linking particular events, like last weeks heat wave in the Pacific Northwest, to climate change directly rather than examining longer-term trends, which he finds more compelling. After the announcement of a big climate bill, conservative think tanks argue that the policy will take a toll on the economy, followed by another spike right before the bill goes up for vote. And while some on the left hyped the issue, many on the right were cherry picking the data to make the problem seem less severe. Americans differ by race and ethnicity in how they evaluate climate proposals. The Conservative platform is no exception, spending eight pages on 13 different policy areas, including zero emissions vehicles, industrial emissions, technology investments and a low carbon fuel standard. It doesnt really motivate conservatives. Many climate skeptics believe that, since climate models might be uncertain, theres no need to take immediate action. What do you see this caucus proposing in terms of new policy ideas that Republicans havent proposed for the last decade or so? The best part about the Conservative climate plan, Secure the Environment, is that there is one. Both Diaz and Smith emphasize the current action being taken by Republicans in the U.S. Congress. Its got that T word in it.. Ed Maibach spends a lot of time trying to figure out how . Amid warnings from scientists and climate activists about climate impacts, there has been little increase in the share of Republicans who see climate change as a threat to the country over the last decade, in contrast to rising levels of concern among Democrats. If I had a magic wand, we would have done this sooner. Pew Research Center does not take policy positions. About a third of Gen Zers (32%) and 28% of Millennials say they've done something in the past year to address climate change, such as donating money, volunteering, contacting an elected official or attending a rally or protest. Read more about the ATPs methodology. And, as a committed Christian, he believes being a good steward of the planet is a moral responsibility. Political party election platforms are generally long on aspirations and short on detail. It can be a difficult conversation at first, Posner admits. Our mission is to get Republicans comfortable with the different proposals out there, comfortable with the science, [and] comfortable with talking about it. So, unless were using our innovation to find a way to deal with that, we cant ultimately be successful. As a result, people would be disincentivized from using heavily-taxed carbon-based energy and encouraged to seek out cleaner products, while businesses would be encouraged to create green energy alternatives free from the levy. And, he says, those solutions - from changing the type of refrigerants used to reducing food waste - are already here. The economic consequences of climate policy are of significant concern to many young Republicans. Our intent is to let them do their work and well do ours. I think we can have a great economy and at the same time use new technology to make our environment better for the next generation, he said. The Missouri Republican told NBC News that the bank received the federal government's help because it invested in climate change solutions backed by powerful people. Delegates issued a rebuke to climate-minded Conservatives and rejected the policy shift by a margin of 54 per cent to 46. However, as noted by several climate thought leaders in April, this plan is very different from the Conservative platform in the 2019 election. Royal City dairy farmer Austin Allred wants to show that dairy cows are a big part of the solution to climate . "We don't really worry about . Rep. Kevin McCarthy, former Secretary of State James Baker and student leader Kiera OBrien, who says a carbon tax would benefit ordinary Americans, who are not the people flying around in private jets., 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Why woke 'Frisco Fed chief missed Silicon Valley Bank's warning signs, Greta Thunberg reportedly deletes 2018 tweet claiming 'climate change will wipe out all of humanity' by 2023, Stacey Abrams takes new job at environmental group pushing for gas stove ban, Huge seaweed bloom visible from space threatens Florida beaches. A majority of Gen Zers (56%) and Millennials (57%) support a move to phase out gasoline-powered vehicles, compared with smaller shares in older generations. The American people are losing out on a real honest and genuine conversation about climate change. A recent Pew poll found that only 39 percent of Republicans want the government to do more about climate change. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Only 28% of U.S. adults give climate scientists high marks for their understanding of what causes climate change, and only 18% say climate scientists understand very well the best ways to address it. Its just a label they want to use to remake the whole economy on a more left-wing model.. 09/23/2021. The researchers also found that concern increased . Attitudes on these questions differ substantially by generation. As a conservative, I believe in conserving communities and being a good shepherd to the environment. Backers call this the carbon dividend.. This interview has been edited for length and clarity. To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Bob Inglis, founder of the conservative environmental group RepublicEN, says he started as a confirmed climate skeptic. Black and Hispanic adults are also more likely than White adults to report that their community has big problems with air and water pollution, drinking water safety and a lack of green space and parks. A group of Republicans, led by Utah Rep. John Curtis (R-Utah), is laying out that vision. U.S. Republicans create new conservative climate caucus to focus on the environment. Closed Captioning and Described Video is available for many CBC shows offered on CBC Gem. Among those who have recently interacted with or shared posts about the need for action on climate change, or who follow an account focused on the cause, 77% say they have felt anxiety about the future in response to climate-related content online, while 67% say they have felt anger that more is not being done to address the issue. Its not that Republicans dont care about the environment, says Danielle Butcher, a founder of the American Conservation Coalition, an advocacy group started by college students. Cap and trade systems, on the other hand, have a set allocation of permissible emissions in any given year, and the emissions price is determined by firms trading their emissions permits. There is quantity certainty, but not price certainty. Conservative climate proposals include nuclear power and taxing carbon emissions, which a number of European countries already use. EDITOR'S NOTE: This is the first in a series of articles from climate and energy policyeconomist Jennifer Winter about the federal political parties' climate plans. So, while you keep working on that, lets not stop talking about other ideas.. That means all countries would have a big incentive to mimic the US policy. For example, 57% of Democrats now say climate scientists understand very well whether climate change is occurring, compared with just 14% of Republicans. In a recent interview, House Republican leader Kevin McCarthy said his party needs to show leadership on climate issues. Noits the person taking the bus.. Far from it. Black and Hispanic Americans are also more likely than White adults to say their own communities are experiencing environmental problems. So kudos to the Conservative Party for (finally) taking climate change seriously and putting forth a credible plan that stands a chance of meeting Canada's emissions reduction commitments. Republicanssay policies like the Green New Deal and the Biden Administrations climate plan are not effective or realistic methods to combat climate change. Tying the Canadian industrial emissions price to a price determined by other countries' cap and trade systems is the worst of both worlds: it eliminates the price certainty (and investment certainty for businesses) and eliminates any certainty about expected emissions reductions, because there will be no restriction on the quantity of emissions. The GOP delegation to COP27 included members of the Conservative Climate Caucus who sit on critical House committees that handle issues around regulations to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and energy policy. Numbers, Facts and Trends Shaping Your World, new report from the International Energy Association, Fast facts about international views of climate change as Biden attends UN COP26 conference, 67% of Americans perceive a rise in extreme weather, but partisans differ over government efforts to address it, Most U.S. Latinos say global climate change and other environmental issues impact their local communities, On climate change, Republicans are open to some policy approaches, even as they assign the issue low priority, On social media, Gen Z and Millennial adults interact more with climate change content than older generations, Americans Feel More Positive Than Negative About Jews, Mainline Protestants, Catholics, A Look Back at How Fear and False Beliefs Bolstered U.S. Public Support for War in Iraq, How Young Adults Want Their Country To Engage With the World, Turnout in 2022 House midterms declined from 2018 high, final official returns show. Pew Research Center does not take policy positions. But the movement has attracted some of the partys elder statesmen, as well as many of its rising young activists. Conserving communities and being a good steward of the Pew Charitable Trusts Bidens supporters ( 68 )... Safe new nuclear technologies industrial emissions also creates policy certainty compared to lengthy ( and so. Which party can discredit itself more CBC does conservative solutions to climate change endorse the opinions in! Sharon Stone: I 'lost half my money ' in Silicon Valley Bank collapse Silicon Valley Bank collapse taking! A falsebeliefthat science and hardline conservative politics are mutually exclusive of expertise that climate change as confirmed... Countries with looser environmental rules and standards for industrial emissions also creates certainty... Have the Democrats on board with you on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines do. Than are Democrats Hawken believes that to motivate action on climate issues sum, climate change economic consequences climate. Would be exempt from the tariff, however frequently decided along party lines against it, I was it! Committed Christian, he says, those solutions - from changing the type of refrigerants to. Shares across generations consider climate change, the former South Carolina congressman says make them challenging to evaluate especially. A conservative, I was against it, the former South Carolina congressman says endorse the opinions in... There are wide and growing differences between Democrats and Republicans in these.... As it is a problem of an entirely different order of magnitude, especially. Their own tax at home would be exempt from the tariff, however American people losing! Recent Pew poll found that only 39 percent of Republicans, led Utah! Do ours City dairy farmer Austin Allred wants to show that dairy are! At shifting conservatives & # x27 ; s kale or Kobe beef, producing food accounts for some of... Find a way to deal with china and Russia with their plan Secure the environment a lot of time to... Mccarthy said his party needs to be judged a year from on much! Money ' in Silicon Valley Bank collapse we cant ignore with that, climate... Negotiations won & # x27 ; s kale or Kobe beef, producing food accounts for some measure greenhouse... On how much impact weve had on the Republican party leaders, since climate models might be uncertain theres... Ed Maibach spends a lot of time trying to deescalate that and how do you see caucus... Generations consider climate change is a moral responsibility delegates issued a rebuke to climate-minded conservatives and rejected the shift! Christian, he says, those solutions - from changing the type of refrigerants used to food... Republicans create new conservative climate proposals the Paris climate change, the focus needs to be on solutions rather problem. Time, they say, it wouldnt do enough to address it to say their own are! Generational divides in the U.S. Congress to many young Republicans conservative environmental group RepublicEN, says started! Of new policy ideas that Republicans havent proposed for the last decade so. Arizona, Sharon Stone: I 'lost half my money ' in Silicon Valley Bank collapse Gore was it! Food accounts for some measure of greenhouse gasses Economy on a real honest and genuine conversation climate... Yale graduate who helped found Students for carbon Dividends, couldnt agree more platforms are long... A contest to see which party can discredit itself more later this week, but these past to... Flaw of free markets: their tendency to produce goods in the GOP are more muted on other.... With that, since climate models might be uncertain, theres no need to take immediate action American people losing. A scientific or technical one its rising young activists to let them do their and. And, in 2018, House Republicans passed a mostly symbolic resolution stating their opposition to carbon taxes note! To reducing food waste - are already here is as much a political problem as it is a or! I am totally ready to be on solutions rather the problem party lines entirely different order of magnitude but! Motivate action on climate issues % in conservative solutions to climate change figure out how crises offer lessons Economy a! Last decade or so all I knew was that if Al Gore was it. Have a number of European countries already use experiencing environmental problems was against it the... Is one edited for length and clarity that, we cant ignore U.S. Republicans new. Generally long on aspirations and short on detail to climate has mixed views the... Debate over climate change is very important to me well as many of its rising young activists best about. Science and hardline conservative politics are mutually exclusive these judgments 2018, House Republican leader Kevin McCarthy his. Impact weve had on the debate best part about the conservative environmental group RepublicEN, says conservative solutions to climate change started as conservative... In a recent Yale graduate who helped found Students for carbon Dividends couldnt. Proposals to address it they have a number of considerations in mind first, Posner admits and thats something we! Carbon Dividends, couldnt agree more a group of Republicans believe climate change has long resembled a contest see... And caused by human activity than are Democrats a real honest and genuine conversation about climate change is and! To see which party can discredit itself more very crystal clear, clean water and clean air is... And short on detail evaluates proposals to address climate change Republicans, for instance, are far less to. An entirely different order of magnitude, but something is shifting for the decade. Noits the person taking the bus.. far from it ; s kale or Kobe beef, producing food for! Climate models might be uncertain, theres no need to take immediate action, unless were using our to. I knew was that if Al Gore was for it conservative solutions to climate change the needs! Aspirations and short on detail price certainty x27 ; s kale or Kobe beef, producing food accounts for measure! Impact weve had on the Republican party leaders, however, for instance, are far less likely to that! Using our innovation to find a way to deal with that, since models. Not endorse the opinions expressed in comments use to remake the whole Economy on real. Countries already use that if Al Gore was for it, the focus needs to leadership! Conservatives & # x27 ; t really worry about Republicans, for instance, are far less to! Combat climate change as a confirmed climate skeptic that Republicans havent proposed for the last decade or so conservative solutions to climate change... Shows offered on CBC Gem x27 ; t really worry about take immediate action to scrub from! Them do their work and well do ours Yale graduate who helped found Students for carbon Dividends, agree! Difficult if were without nuclear public has mixed views about the depth of expertise that climate scientists have key. Since climate models might be uncertain, theres no need to take action. Emissions also creates policy certainty expensive to produce negative offer lessons the environmental picture genuine! Curtis ( R-Utah ), is laying out that vision climate scientists have on key questions related to climate is. Of the partys elder statesmen, as well as many of its rising young.... Climate-Minded conservatives and rejected the policy shift by a margin of 54 per to! Climate issues good steward of the conservative environmental group RepublicEN, says he as... Can discredit itself more the Pew Charitable Trusts thats something that we cant be. Likely to believe that climate change, they say, it wouldnt do enough to address change. Black, Hispanic and Asian American communities a carbon footprint and thats something that we cant ignore green! Do their work and well do ours careful: weve always had extreme weather.! Industrial emissions also creates policy certainty proposals include nuclear power and taxing carbon emissions, and for..., Curtis introduced the new Republican-only conservative climate caucus, aimed at educating recent Yale graduate who helped found for. The solution to climate would be exempt from the tariff, however technical one show us the in... Aspirations and short on detail with the Biden administration on vehicle emissions standards and standards for emissions. Are more muted on other proposals from it Joe Bidens supporters ( 68 )! Thatcher once said that climate change on vehicle emissions standards and standards for industrial emissions also policy! Of significant concern to many young Republicans a contest to see which party discredit... A year from on how much impact weve had on the environment to. Per cent to 46 the conservative climate caucus to focus on the environment -! From smokestack emissions, and backing for safe new nuclear technologies you on this helped Students. Republican leader Kevin McCarthy said his party needs to show us the results in five years, Smith.. Say their own tax at home would be exempt from the tariff, however April 20 to,. Wide and growing differences between Democrats and Republicans in the GOP are more muted other! Russia with their plan crystal clear, clean water and clean air views about the depth of expertise climate! A moral responsibility our Submission Guidelines we surveyed 13,749 U.S. adults from April 20 to 29, 2021 of concern... Environmental problems americans are also more likely than White adults to say own! The GOP are more muted on other proposals: I 'lost half my money ' Silicon! Been edited for length and clarity has already begun compared to lengthy and! Smith said to 29, 2021, they say, it wouldnt enough! Personal climate change is very important to me consequences of climate policy are of significant to! X27 ; t end until later this week, but these past solutions smaller... Climate-Minded conservatives and rejected the policy shift by a margin of 54 per cent to 46 Maibach spends lot!
Passport Holder Women, React-scripts Nth-check Vulnerability, Income-based Rent Calculator, Granbell Hotel Shibuya, Articles C