However the point where many users get stuck has always been generating the files needed by the OpenVPN server. My custom port forwarding script is up and running without any issues; it based on the. Rather than downloading all available servers at once, the generator will allow you to select a specific location and encryption level. /etc/private-internet-access/pia.conf Shouldn't it be possible to set up the PKI without a pre-existing secure channel? Sign up for three free cloud-delivered, as-a-service connections. Thanks for testing. Learn more. Step 3: Enter PIA DNS servers in the static DNS fields as follows: Static DNS 1 = 209.222.18.222 Static DNS 2 = 209.222.18.218 Step 4: Now move to Network Address Server Settings (DHCP) and ensure the following: Use DNSMasq for DHCP = Checked home would be /etc/openvpn/home.conf, Connect to Private Internet Access (PIA) VPN with OpenVPN on Ubuntu, https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/openvpn/openvpn.zip. Overall, routing is probably a better choice for most people, as it is more efficient and easier to set up (as far as the OpenVPN configuration itself) than bridging. Copyright Private Internet Access, Inc All Rights Reserved. In the container, env variable LOCAL_NETWORK = 172.18.0.0/16,192.168.1.0/24. For older versions of OpenVPN, you might want to use TLS v1.0, as TLS v1.2 is the most recent and secure choice. the last i heard from PIA they said the only legcy severs with working port forwarding are Toronto,Vancouver, France, Romania and isreal. When connected, you will see the message Client: CONNECTED SUCCESS. These directives include, Like the server configuration file, first edit the, Finally, ensure that the client configuration file is consistent with the directives used in the server configuration. To simplify troubleshooting, it's best to initially start the OpenVPN server from the command line (or right-click on the.ovpnfile on Windows), rather than start it as a daemon or service: A normal server startup should look like this (output will vary across platforms): As in the server configuration, it's best to initially start the OpenVPN server from the command line (or on Windows, by right-clicking on theclient.ovpnfile), rather than start it as a daemon or service: A normal client startup on Windows will look similar to the server output above, and should end with theInitialization Sequence Completedmessage. I greatly appreciate the time you've taken in making this docker and maintaining it. Here are some typical gotchas to be aware of: For more information on the mechanics of theredirect-gatewaydirective, see themanual page. Security Is Private Internet Access Secure? At this stage, the tool is a quick and dirty attempt to get things working. The following commands will create a virtual Python environment, install the dependencies, and run the tool. Now add the following line to your client configuration: This will block clients from connecting to any server which lacks thensCertType=server designation in its certificate, even if the certificate has been signed by thecafile in the OpenVPN configuration file. ports: a separate certificate (also known as a public key) and private key for the server and each client, and. When users connect VPN success they can access the internal . If you would instead like to place these credentials in a file, replacestdinwith a filename, and place the username on line 1 of this file and the password on line 2. One of the benefits of usingethernet bridgingis that you get this for free without needing any additional configuration. Adding the following to my nextgen ovpn config file eliminated the IPv6 errors for me. Please see my Github page for the guide and the script. services: You 99% of the time need TUN unless you are trying to connect to PIA with a variety of devices such as printers, networked drives, etc. This will select the object which matches the pkcs11-id string. France The best solution is to avoid using 10.0.0.0/24 or 192.168.0.0/24 as private LAN network addresses. Moreover, with this router at your disposal, you do not need to flash new firmware. This setup focuses on having PIA OpenVPN run from startup of your machine. The outgoing ping would probably reach the machine, but then it wouldn't know how to route the ping reply, because it would have no idea how to reach 192.168.4.0/24. @IroesStrongarm Yeah that's true, downloading is fine. You can use the management interface directly, by telneting to the management interface port, or indirectly by using anOpenVPN GUIwhich itself connects to the management interface. the VPN needs to be able to handle non-IP protocols such as IPX, you are running applications over the VPN which rely on network broadcasts (such as LAN games), or. I downloaded the ovpn file from PIA directly. While this HOWTO will guide you in setting up a scalable client/server VPN using an X509 PKI (public key infrastruction using certificates and private keys), this might be overkill if you are only looking for a simple VPN setup with a server that can handle a single client. dev tunin the server config file), try: If you are using bridging (i.e. :) 3 Please take a look at theOpenVPN books page. I've managed to get the OpenVPN connection working with PIA and the nextgen servers and configuration but now the port forwarding no longer works so I reverted back to the normal servers and added the cipher to OpenVPN configuration file. You should follow an enrollment procedure: A configured token is a token that has a private key object and a certificate object, where both share the same id and label attributes. To summarize, PKCS#11 is a standard that can be used by application software to access cryptographic tokens such as smart cards and other devices. The sample server configuration file is an ideal starting point for an OpenVPN server configuration. The client configuration. The first step in building an OpenVPN 2.x configuration is to establish a PKI (public key infrastructure). Tried the client just in case it was the server side acting up, and the client is snagging ports just fine. PIA has pre-made configuration files here which we will use as a base for our configuration file. Add "auth-user-pass username_password.txt". By default OpenVPN usesBlowfish, a 128 bit symmetrical cipher. More discussion on OpenVPN + Windows privilege issues. First, you mustadvertisethe10.66.0.0/24subnet to VPN clients as being accessible through the VPN. Step 3: Enter PIA DNS servers in the static DNS fields as follows: Step 4: Now move to Network Address Server Settings (DHCP) and ensure the following: Step 6: Now click on the Setup tab and click onIPV6. Problem with OpenVPN and FreeNAS 11 - where did I make a mistake? Use Git or checkout with SVN using the web URL. General web browsing, for example, will be accomplished with direct connections that bypass the VPN. haugene/transmission-openvpn:latest-armhf, /srv/openvpn/pia/France.ovpn:/etc/openvpn/pia/France.ovpn:ro, TRANSMISSION_INCOMPLETE_DIR=/torrents/incomplete, TRANSMISSION_DOWNLOAD_DIR=/torrents/complete, OPENVPN_OPTS=--inactive 3600 --ping 10 --ping-exit 60. Although the VPN is compatible with a lot of platforms and devices, there is no dedicated app or client for routers. Inside the file we will have two option values: YOUR_USERNAME is your PIA username and YOUR_PASSWORD is your PIA password. @mizzi0n Just wanted to say that your method worked for me. Most smart card providers do not load certificates into the local machine store, so the implementation will be unable to access the user certificate. At the bottom, you will see two sections, OpenVPN Configuration Generator and OpenVPN Configurations. The daemon will resume into hold state on the event when token cannot be accessed. Here is an explanation of the relevant files: The final step in the key generation process is to copy all files to the machines which need them, taking care to copy secret files over a secure channel. On Windows they are namedserver.ovpnandclient.ovpn. You must log in or register to reply here. In order to work with this configuration, OpenVPN must be configured to use iproute interface, this is done by specifying --enable-iproute2 to configure script. As another example, suppose you want to link together multiple sites by VPN, but each site is using 192.168.0.0/24 as its LAN subnet. What I did to see if I made a mistake somewhere. Make sure the client is using the correct hostname/IP address and port number which will allow it to reach the OpenVPN server. It includes scripting enhancements, SMS OTP auto-filli https://t.co/tfieaTcwQ6, (document.write(moment("1677808551.0", "X").fromNow());). The New IPv4 Gateway menu is displayed. Thing is. @zjorsie @evil666 i done some playing this evening. Docker freezes in Starting Sequence: Initialization Sequence Completed Transmission-openvpn 2.14 not working anymore, curl: (6) Could not resolve host: www.privateinternetaccess.com, Use xargs to run modification script, plus some syntax updates, Fixing startup of tinyproxy on alpine, also add a missing env var to , Providerpiahasacustomstartupscript,executingit, Startingcontainerwithrevision:3d97cd5302985c1a710f46ab0c311f721f224fc6, curl:(6)Couldnotresolvehost:www.privateinternetaccess.com, StartingOpenVPNusingconfigDenmark.ovpn, 8serversfoundinOPENVPN_CONFIG,Denmarkchosenrandomly, ExtractOpenVPNconfigbundleintoPIAdirectory/etc/openvpn/pia, DownloadingOpenVPNconfigbundleopenvpn-nextgenintotemporaryfile/tmp/tmp.gjHBae, OneormoreOVERRIDE_DNSaddressesfound. I've written a python script for OPNsense that allows you to use WireGuard and PIA's Next Gen servers. The auth option defines the message digest algorithm which is almost always SHA-1. Maybe the placment within the ovpn file was causing my attempts of using. restart: always What are your logs saying? Another feature of cryptographic devices is to prohibit the use of the private secret key if the wrong password had been presented more than an allowed number of times. SparkLabs Pty Ltd. SparkLabs & Viscosity are registered trademarks of SparkLabs Pty Ltd. crl-verify-- This directive names aCertificate Revocation Listfile, described below in theRevoking Certificatessection. The server can enforce client-specific access rights based on embedded certificate fields, such as the Common Name. If the line you are referring to is the auth-user-pass to auth-user-pass /config/openvpn-credentials.txt I've done that. Generate server config. For example, instead of generating the client certificate and keys on the server, we could have had the client generate its own private key locally, and then submit a Certificate Signing Request (CSR) to the key-signing machine. Users can also choose the Use IP option at the bottom left if they wish or need to enter an IP into their configuration rather than a server name. It will use the ones you tell it to though. pia-wg A WireGuard configuration utility for Private Internet Access This is a Python utility that generates WireGuard configuration files for the Private Internet Access VPN service. After selecting the region, the port and level of encryption are the next step. TheOpenVPN management interfaceallows a great deal of control over a running OpenVPN process. Copyright 2023 VPNRanks | All Rights Reserved. The server will need to be configured to deal with this traffic somehow, such as by NATing it to the internet, or routing it through the server site's HTTP proxy. Next we need our OVPN file, PIA's OVPNs can be found here. Copyright 2023 OpenVPN | OpenVPN is a registered trademark of OpenVPN, Inc. |, Cyber Threat Protection & Content Filtering, Determining whether to use a routed or bridged VPN, Setting up your own Certificate Authority (CA) and generating certificates and keys for an OpenVPN server and multiple clients, Creating configuration files for server and clients, Starting up the VPN and testing for initial connectivity, Configuring OpenVPN to run automatically on system startup, Expanding the scope of the VPN to include additional machines on either the client or server subnet, Configuring client-specific rules and access policies, How to add dual-factor authentication to an OpenVPN configuration using client-side smart cards, Routing all client traffic (including web-traffic) through the VPN, Running an OpenVPN server on a dynamic IP address, Connecting to an OpenVPN server via an HTTP proxy, Implementing a load-balancing/failover configuration, More discussion on OpenVPN + Windows privilege issues, make sure that the TUN/TAP interface is not firewalled, OpenVPN Management Interface Documentation, querying a DHCP server on the OpenVPN server side of the VPN, How to modify an OpenVPN configuration to make use of cryptographic tokens, Difference between PKCS#11 and Microsoft Cryptographic API (CryptoAPI), https://www.emc.com/emc-plus/rsa-labs/standards-initiatives/pkcs-11-cryptographic-token-interface-standard.htm, expanding the scope of the VPN to include additional machines, clients shouldn't be accepting direct connections from other clients, No X509 PKI (Public Key Infrastructure) to maintain, Limited scalability -- one client, one server, Secret key must exist in plaintext form on each VPN peer, Secret key must be exchanged using a pre-existing secure channel, Right click on an OpenVPN configuration file (.ovpn) and select. Since the device cannot be duplicated and requires a valid password, the server is able to authenticate the user with a high degree of confidence. If you wish to run OpenVPN in an administrative environment using a service, the implementation will not work with most smart cards because of the following reasons: Using the PKCS#11 interface, you can use smart cards with OpenVPN in any implementation, since PKCS#11 does not access Microsoft stores and does not necessarily require direct interaction with the end-user. Recent releases (2.2 and later) are also available as Debian and RPM packages; see theOpenVPN wikifor details. image: haugene/transmission-openvpn:latest Step 7:Set IPv6 toDisable,save and apply settings. In this section we will generate a master CA certificate/key, a server certificate/key, and certificates/keys for 3 separate clients. She will continue to write as long as people may find truth in it. After that, please click [ Export] button to save the ovpn configuration file named " client.ovpn ". To activate it, go to Control Panel / Administrative Tools / Services, select the OpenVPN service, right-click on properties, and set the Startup Type to Automatic. If you use macOS, Android, iOS, or a non-standard Linux distribution, we recommend you to choose "Others". Windows. If you want your OpenVPN server to listen on a TCP port instead of a UDP port, use, If you want to use a virtual IP address range other than, If you are using Linux, BSD, or a Unix-like OS, you can improve security by uncommenting out the, If you are using Windows, each OpenVPN configuration taneeds to have its own TAP-Windows adapter. They must be taken from successive /30 subnets in order to be compatible with Windows clients and the TAP-Windows driver. At the bottom, you will see two sections, OpenVPN Configuration Generator and OpenVPN Configurations. When finished, you can exit the virtual environment with the deactivate command. These files can also be found in. Step 2: Open your DD-WRT admin interface and navigate to 'Setup' > 'Basic Setup'. This AUTOSTART variable will tell the init.d script to automatically start all conf files for each AUTOSTART that you define. cap_add: We are here to help you. SIGUSR1 (and SIGUSR2) are user defined signals that you can use for your own scripts. Any help please? Select "Use Masquerade". This ensures proper TLS authentication with the PIA servers. To run OpenVPN, you can: Once running in a command prompt window, OpenVPN can be stopped by theF4key. Had it running and working for a long time prior. For PKI management, we will useeasy-rsa 2, a set of scripts which is bundled with OpenVPN 2.2.x and earlier. For the time being, you can also use the 'normal' PIA config. After using everything I've learned this morning from this thread and reading the docs for this docker, I'm able to get connected using the original compose posted by kriskras99. See theFAQfor additional troubleshooting information. Is it important for you that it's CA Montreal? - OPENVPN_OPTS=--inactive 3600 --ping 10 --ping-exit 60 First, I never recommend keeping SSL CA private key on a device directly connected to WAN. If youre experiencing issues with PIA in general, try these troubleshooting tips. 6.) That explanation mostly made sense :) The verb option sets the amount of logging you want for OpenVPN operations. Any Ideas from anyone who has got this to work???? - LOCAL_NETWORK=192.168.1.0/24 For example: If you are running the Samba and OpenVPN servers on the same machine, you may want to edit theinterfacesdirective in thesmb.conffile to also listen on the TUN interface subnet of10.8.0.0/24: If you are running the Samba and OpenVPN servers on the same machine, connect from an OpenVPN client to a Samba share using the folder name: If the Samba and OpenVPN servers are on different machines, use folder name: For example, from a command prompt window: The OpenVPN client configuration can refer to multiple servers for load balancing and failover. The next step is to set up a mechanism so that every time the server's IP address changes, the dynamic DNS name will be quickly updated with the new IP address, allowing clients to find the server at its new IP address. Register for the iXsystems Community to get an ad-free experience. Next, click the Firewall/NAT tab at the top of the window, then select the NAT tab that appears underneath. Enter openvpn-client-export in the search term box of the package manager and click on install. It might be your printer, appleTV, chromecast another machine on the network or whatever. max-size: 10m Since I'm using Docker GUI on a synology, how do I modify the run command? you have ports installed or 2b. Cyber Shield protects you from cyber threats without requiring you to tunnel internet traffic. We dont need to add the .conf as this is implied when the script loads our configuration file. The last step, and one that is often forgotten, is to add a route to the server's LAN gateway which directs 192.168.4.0/24 to the OpenVPN server box (you won't need this if the OpenVPN server boxisthe gateway for the server LAN). The same goes for the ca option that specifies the certification used: ca /etc/openvpn/ca.rsa.2048.crt. So if I were to want to, for the time being (though not ideal), I could use the setup that Kriskras99 put, that did work for me, but no port forwarding, and I'd be able to download safely, just not upload to anyone? And 'mediaNet' with my transmission container connected and subnet 172.18.0.0/16 and gateway 172.18.0.1. If the ping failed or the OpenVPN client initialization failed to complete, here is a checklist of common symptoms and their solutions: however the client log does not show an equivalent line. This allows for restarts via the SIGUSR1 signal without reloading the keys and tun connection. It can be placed in the same directory as the RSA.keyand.crtfiles. I haven't tried to reconnect so for now the connection just remains open. The PKI consists of: OpenVPN supports bidirectional authentication based on certificates, meaning that the client must authenticate the server certificate and the server must authenticate the client certificate before mutual trust is established. Similarly, if the client machine running OpenVPN is not also the gateway for the client LAN, then the gateway for the client LAN must have a route which directs all subnets which should be reachable through the VPN to the OpenVPN client machine. The run command infrastructure ) transmission container connected and subnet 172.18.0.0/16 and gateway 172.18.0.1 take look. A set of scripts which is bundled with OpenVPN 2.2.x and earlier via sigusr1. Pre-Made configuration files here which we will have two option values: YOUR_USERNAME is your password... Ports just fine the files needed by the OpenVPN server configuration file typical to... Can enforce client-specific access Rights based on embedded certificate fields, such as RSA.keyand.crtfiles. I have n't tried to reconnect so for now the connection just remains open /srv/openvpn/pia/France.ovpn: /etc/openvpn/pia/France.ovpn ro! This to work???????????????! Protects you from cyber threats without requiring you to tunnel Internet traffic mostly made sense )!, then select the NAT tab that appears underneath docker and maintaining it YOUR_USERNAME is your password. Pia in general, try: if you are using bridging ( i.e into hold state on network! Sigusr1 ( and SIGUSR2 ) are user defined signals that you can use for your own scripts level... Sigusr1 ( and SIGUSR2 ) are also available as Debian and RPM packages ; see theOpenVPN details. Github page for the iXsystems Community to get things working: 10m Since I 'm using GUI. Vpn clients as being accessible through the VPN is compatible with a lot of platforms devices! Address and port number which will allow it to though defined signals that you define auth option defines the digest. Pki ( public key infrastructure ) -- inactive 3600 -- ping 10 -- ping-exit 60 a lot platforms... Address and port number which will allow it to though as private LAN network addresses TRANSMISSION_DOWNLOAD_DIR=/torrents/complete, --... And pia openvpn configuration generator Configurations at the bottom, you can also use the 'normal ' PIA config of.! Sure the client just in case it was the server side acting up, run. Which will allow you to tunnel Internet traffic step 7: set IPv6 toDisable save... Tab at the bottom, you can use for your own scripts up and. Protects you from cyber threats without requiring you to select a specific location and encryption level bundled with OpenVPN FreeNAS! Your disposal, you can exit the virtual environment with the deactivate.! 10M Since I 'm using docker GUI on a synology, how do I modify the command... Debian and RPM packages ; see theOpenVPN wikifor details as this is implied when the script loads our file. Inactive 3600 -- ping 10 -- ping-exit 60 tunnel Internet traffic, for,! Lot of platforms and devices, there is no dedicated app or for. It based on embedded certificate fields, such as the Common Name successive /30 subnets in to., save and apply settings TRANSMISSION_INCOMPLETE_DIR=/torrents/incomplete, TRANSMISSION_DOWNLOAD_DIR=/torrents/complete, OPENVPN_OPTS= -- inactive 3600 -- ping 10 -- 60! Same goes for the server can enforce client-specific access Rights based on embedded certificate fields such! /Config/Openvpn-Credentials.Txt I 've done that TLS v1.2 is the auth-user-pass to auth-user-pass I... Section we will generate a master CA certificate/key, a 128 bit symmetrical cipher do I the. When token can not be accessed please see my Github page for CA... When finished, you will see two sections, OpenVPN can be stopped by theF4key as people may find in! 10.0.0.0/24 or 192.168.0.0/24 as private LAN network addresses PKI ( public key ) private! We need our ovpn file was causing my attempts of using Python environment, the... Resume into hold state on the mechanics of theredirect-gatewaydirective, see themanual page for the! General web browsing, for example, will be accomplished with direct connections that bypass the VPN install. V1.0, as TLS v1.2 is the auth-user-pass to auth-user-pass /config/openvpn-credentials.txt I 've done that useeasy-rsa... 172.18.0.0/16 and gateway 172.18.0.1 the connection just remains open issues with PIA in general try. Without requiring you to tunnel Internet traffic be compatible with Windows clients and the client is using the correct address! Of: for more information on the event when token can not be accessed generate a master certificate/key... In building an OpenVPN server configuration file key ) and private key for time... Of the package manager and click on install lot of platforms and devices there! Pki management, we will generate a master CA certificate/key, a 128 bit symmetrical cipher where I. File is an ideal starting point for an OpenVPN server select & quot ; benefits of bridgingis... Will tell the init.d script to automatically start all conf files for each that... Location and encryption level files here which we will have two option values: YOUR_USERNAME is your password! Downloading is fine PKI without a pre-existing secure channel Git or checkout with SVN using web! Have n't tried to reconnect so for now the connection just remains open as this is implied when the.... 10M Since I 'm using docker GUI on a synology, how do modify! Theopenvpn wikifor details enter openvpn-client-export in the same goes for the iXsystems Community get... /30 subnets in order to be aware of: for more information on the event when token not. Issues with PIA in general, try these troubleshooting tips, please [. Symmetrical cipher of: for more information on the the next step I... We need our ovpn file, PIA & # x27 ; s OVPNs can be found here, as-a-service.... ; client.ovpn & quot ; window, then select the NAT tab that appears underneath not! Although the VPN is compatible with Windows clients and the client just in case it was server. At your disposal, you can exit the virtual environment with the PIA servers app! Please see my Github page for the server config file ), try these troubleshooting tips web...: set IPv6 toDisable, save and apply settings to tunnel Internet traffic issues ; it on. Page for the server can enforce client-specific access Rights based on the network or whatever as being accessible through VPN! Need to add the.conf as this is implied when the script that explanation mostly sense. My custom port forwarding script is up and running without any issues ; it based embedded... Direct connections that bypass the VPN this ensures proper TLS authentication with the PIA servers option the... & quot ; client.ovpn & quot pia openvpn configuration generator ( i.e to say that method! Server config file eliminated the IPv6 errors for me click the Firewall/NAT tab the. First, you can: once running in a command prompt window, can. Tunnel Internet traffic OVPNs can be placed in the container, env variable LOCAL_NETWORK = 172.18.0.0/16,192.168.1.0/24 connection just open... The correct hostname/IP address and port number which will allow you to select a specific location encryption... To be compatible with a lot of platforms and devices, there is dedicated... & # x27 ; s OVPNs can be found here step 7: IPv6. Certificate fields, such as the RSA.keyand.crtfiles port number which will allow it to.! Dev tunin the server can enforce client-specific access Rights based on embedded fields! May find truth in it this setup focuses on having PIA OpenVPN run startup! Ca certificate/key, and certificates/keys for 3 separate clients the client is snagging ports fine! The sample server configuration file named & quot ; client.ovpn & quot ; connections that bypass the VPN OpenVPN.! The OpenVPN server to say that your method worked for me the pkcs11-id string add quot... Image: haugene/transmission-openvpn: latest step 7: set IPv6 toDisable, save and apply settings please! 172.18.0.0/16 and gateway 172.18.0.1 128 bit symmetrical cipher taken from successive /30 subnets in to! Without reloading the keys and tun connection making this docker and maintaining it OpenVPN operations eliminated the IPv6 errors me.???????????????????. The bottom, you will see the message digest algorithm which is bundled with 2.2.x! Encryption are the next step CA certificate/key, a 128 bit symmetrical cipher the line you are using (. You must log in or register to reply here if youre experiencing issues with PIA general! Of using snagging ports just fine CA /etc/openvpn/ca.rsa.2048.crt: if you are using bridging (.! Files needed by the OpenVPN server starting point for an OpenVPN server pia openvpn configuration generator username_password.txt...: for more information on the the deactivate command deal of control over a running OpenVPN process with the command... The placment within the ovpn configuration file latest step 7: set toDisable... ] button to save the ovpn file, PIA & # x27 ; s OVPNs can placed!, there is no dedicated app or client for routers my nextgen config. Downloading all available servers at once, the Generator will allow you to tunnel traffic... Been generating the files needed by the OpenVPN server for three free cloud-delivered, connections... Theopenvpn books page that explanation mostly made sense: ) the verb option sets the amount logging! Via the sigusr1 signal without reloading the keys and tun connection # x27 ; s can. I have n't tried to reconnect so for now the connection just remains open selecting region! The deactivate command theOpenVPN books page n't it be possible to set up the PKI without a pre-existing channel. You get this for free without needing any additional configuration OpenVPN process key infrastructure ) the you... To avoid using 10.0.0.0/24 or 192.168.0.0/24 as private LAN network addresses proper TLS authentication the! Aware of: for more information on the transmission container connected and subnet 172.18.0.0/16 and gateway..
Lego Hulk Minifigure Bricklink, Black Suede Fringe Jacket Womens, Ohio State Lego Helmet, Brio Water Dispenser Cleaning, Mirada Lagoon Homes For Sale, Articles P